Rate the Raters, Phase Two

Taking Inventory of the Ratings Universe

05 Oct 2010 – Report


“Sustainability indexes lack own transparency,” Reuters, 16 September 2010

“When Pigs Fly: Halliburton Makes the Dow Jones Sustainability Index,” RP Siegel, Triple Pundit, 24 September 2010

We’ve seen headlines like these before. In what has become a seasonal occurrence, the release of a new or updated rating of corporate sustainability performance is followed in many quarters by disbelief – even dismay – that some raters are themselves inscrutable and that companies some consider pariahs have been ranked among those deemed most sustainable.

Familiar as this pattern is, with the autumn 2010 release of phase two of our Rate the Raters research program occurring amidst a series of major ratings announcements (from the Carbon Disclosure Project, Dow Jones Sustainability Indices, FTSE4Good, Newsweek and others), there seems to be greater interest and angst than normal among both rated companies and others working on the sustainability agenda.

On the corporate side, some companies may be hitting a boiling point fueled by the effort required to keep track of and respond to the constantly growing number of ratings. Perhaps for others it is the opacity of the ratings organizations’ methodologies and listing/de-listing processes. But we think there is something more profound taking place: ratings are being taken more seriously as they go mainstream. And, as they come to matter more to more stakeholders, the spotlight shines brighter on ratings – and the organizations which create and promote them.

With that in mind, phase two of Rate the Raters is designed to illuminate the breadth and depth of the ratings universe. SustainAbility inventoried over 100 ratings and their attributes, surveyed a global group of sustainability experts on their perceptions of ratings, and analyzed the results.

For insights and analysis, watch SustainAbility’s on-demand video briefing or download the full phase two white paper below.

For further background on this project, see the phase one white paper, in which SustainAbility explored the evolution of the ratings agenda over the last decade and identified key trends and challenges to date.

You must be a member to read and download. It’s free and easy.

Email Share

From the Blog

More from the blog

Latest News

More news


You must have an account with us to gain unlimited access to our ever-growing library of research reports, issue briefings and members-only presentations on the latest sustainability challenges and opportunities for business.

Join now